German cinema · Part 2
Weimar cinema: beyond expressionism
From Die Nibelungen to M: legends, city life and human faces
A continuation of German expressionist cinema.
The cinema of the 1920s and early 1930s is remarkable for the range of experiences it offers. We can enter a medieval legend, watch preparations for a journey to the Moon, then spend a Sunday with a few Berliners. Each film finds its own way of telling a human story.
Germany was one of the leading centres of European cinema during this period. Yet that historical description can obscure the immediate experience of these films: their dramatic depth, beauty and surprising intimacy. Sometimes an actor’s glance or a brief everyday encounter almost erases the distance of a hundred years.
Our first essay explored German expressionism: unsettling spaces, emphatic shadows and unusual figures. Here we broaden the view. The Weimar Republic existed from 1919 to 1933; its cinema encompassed many approaches, with expressionist devices often appearing alongside psychological drama, realism and adventure. There is no rigid boundary between them.
This journey takes in nine films made between 1924 and 1931. The two parts of Die Nibelungen share a chapter. Screenshots from a personal flickollect collection invite comparisons between posters, characters and individual frames. The essay text was written separately from the descriptions visible in the screenshots.
Open any screenshot to explore it full screen. The gallery also offers an original-size view.
01 / Film
Die Nibelungen: the grandeur of legend and the cost of revenge
Siegfried
After Metropolis, it is easy to think of Lang as the builder of immense screen worlds. In Die Nibelungen, this gift serves a medieval legend. Palaces, costumes, the arrangement of people and the rhythm of their movements suggest a solemn order. The characters seem to occupy appointed places in a story larger than any one of them.
The first part, Siegfried, begins as a hero’s journey towards great deeds. Gradually, this magnificent world reveals another side: behind its ceremonies and promises lie rivalry, deception and dependence on other people’s decisions. Strength does not guarantee an understanding of others.
In the selected frame, Siegfried rides a white horse among enormous trees. The bright central figure is surrounded by heavy, dark trunks, with mist separating it from the depths of the forest. The hero’s physical size differs from his importance: he is small within the landscape, yet commands our attention.
Kriemhild’s Revenge
In Kriemhild’s Revenge, the story’s emotional centre shifts. The heroine’s determination gradually draws everything into its orbit. Where the first part invites us to contemplate a beautiful world, the second makes us watch it become a place of reckoning.
Compare the forest with the frame of Hagen holding an exhausted Gunther against a background of fire. Light around a rider gives way to smoke, the weight of a body and the confinement of disaster. Together, the images trace the journey from heroic promise to tragedy.
Further reading
Look more closely
Compare Kriemhild in the character galleries of both films: her expression, headdress and stillness. How does your impression of the same character change?
02 / Film
The Last Laugh: dignity held together by a uniform
From palaces and legendary kings, we move to the entrance of a large hotel. An elderly doorman takes pride in his work and ceremonial uniform. They embody his social standing, his neighbours’ respect and his sense of importance. Reassignment to another job becomes a personal catastrophe.
Emil Jannings conveys the change through his entire body: the way he holds his back, looks at others and occupies a room. A loss of confidence becomes physically tangible. Clothing continues to announce his position even as he tries to conceal what has happened.
Murnau and cinematographer Karl Freund make the camera a mobile participant in the story. It guides us through space and brings us closer to the protagonist’s experience. The almost complete absence of explanatory intertitles is especially striking: images communicate so much.
In the selected frame, the old man sits against the far wall of a washroom. Basins and mirrors occupy most of the space. He seems pushed to the margins of a life continuing without him. Beside the frame, a cover shows the same man in his uniform cap. The contrast tells us about his loss before we know the plot.
Further reading
Look more closely
Follow the line of basins towards the small seated figure. How would the effect change if the camera moved close to him?
03 / Film
Pandora’s Box: a face that resists a final explanation
Lulu is a young woman whose presence disrupts the familiar order of other people’s lives. Desire, jealousy and attempts to control her future gather around her. Calling her simply a fatal seductress would repeat a ready-made judgement without explaining the person.
Louise Brooks holds our attention through effortless changes of mood. A smile, sudden seriousness or a movement of the head can transform a scene without an emphatic gesture. Her freedom on screen makes Lulu difficult to reduce to a moral lesson.
Pabst surrounds her with people who each expect something different. Their ways of looking become significant: one sees a lover, another a possession, another a threat to their position. We must attend to these looks as well as to Lulu’s actions.
In the selected frame, she sits in a pale dress with a hand resting on a man leaning towards her. The gesture suggests both tenderness and distance: her gaze is directed elsewhere. Compare this with the poster, where Brooks’s face has become a recognisable emblem. Within the film, it remains far less fixed.
Further reading
Look more closely
Compare the poster with the frame: the direction of the eyes, the position of the hands and the relationship between the figures.
04 / Film
The White Hell of Pitz Palu: facing the mountains
In the mountain film, space has a power of its own. Ice, altitude, weather and fatigue set limits to human confidence. An ascent may begin as a free choice and quickly become a struggle to return.
The White Hell of Pitz Palu combines adventure with personal drama. For Dr Krafft, the mountains are bound to a loss he cannot escape; an encounter with a young couple draws new people into this story. Spectacular scenery does not diminish the importance of a face, a helping gesture or a sign of exhaustion.
The chosen image shows three figures beside an ice wall. Heavy vertical icicles loom over them. Clothing, a walking stick and the positions of their bodies give the landscape a physical chill. We want to admire the ice while also searching for shelter.
After the studio forest of Die Nibelungen, it is revealing to compare two kinds of screen grandeur. One space is organised as a legend; the other makes us feel how little a human body can set against it.
Further reading
Look more closely
Study the ice wall first, then the people’s postures. Which detail turns a beautiful landscape into a dangerous place?
05 / Film
Woman in the Moon: a dream acquires a blueprint
In Metropolis, Lang showed an entire city of the future. Here, science fiction concentrates on a single undertaking: a flight to the Moon. Preparations, the rocket’s construction and the launch procedure acquire a drama of their own. Attention to detail invites us to believe the journey is possible.
The film remains an adventure involving intrigue, a struggle for lunar gold and romantic rivalry. Scientific curiosity coexists with earthly interests. Even as they leave Earth, people carry familiar desires and conflicts with them.
The rocket cutaway captures the appeal of this kind of science fiction. We can see levels, a ladder, places for people, pipes and mechanisms. We can mentally take the structure apart and imagine moving through it. The flight takes on a material form.
Some of the film’s ideas about the Moon now seem naive. Yet the pleasure of seeing a working machine remains. We are drawn to the passage from an impossible dream to a sequence of actions: design, construction, preparation and launch.
Further reading
Look more closely
Locate the crew’s space in the rocket cutaway. How does the relationship between people and machinery make the imaginary technology convincing?
06 / Film
People on Sunday: a life contained in a day off
After rockets and icy cliffs comes a day trip out of town. Several young Berliners meet, swim, talk, flirt and disappoint one another a little. The ordinary nature of these events gradually becomes their chief attraction.
The film combines a fictional story with observation of real urban life. Its leading performers are non-professionals; their faces do not offer the familiar promise of star spectacle. We watch how they behave before the camera, respond to attention and spend time that finally belongs to them.
In the selected frame, two women sit beside the water, turned towards each other. A small conversational space opens between them. After monumental sets and carefully arranged tragic poses, the scene feels especially immediate. It has value even if nothing decisive happens.
Released in 1930, People on Sunday is a silent film made alongside the developing sound cinema. The coexistence reminds us that an era did not change on a single command: different ways of telling stories continued together.
Further reading
Look more closely
Look at the women’s postures and the direction of their eyes. What makes the conversation feel unforced?
07 / Film
The Blue Angel: voice, desire and lost standing
Professor Immanuel Rath is accustomed to a world in which his position governs his dealings with others. Meeting the singer Lola Lola takes him into a setting with different rules. A man used to instructing everyone around him discovers how fragile his confidence is.
Jannings again plays a loss of dignity, but comparison with The Last Laugh reveals differences. The doorman depends painfully on social respect. The professor also tries to extend his accustomed authority into relationships where it has no force. His behaviour provokes a mixture of pity, embarrassment and irritation.
As Lola Lola, Marlene Dietrich establishes a different rhythm of life. Her voice and singing become part of an attraction that no photograph can convey. Sound cinema can work simultaneously through faces, movement and intonation.
The selected frame places the characters in a cramped room full of objects. The seated Rath looks up at a standing man; Lola is further back. Even without dialogue, the arrangement suggests confidence and dependence. Watching the film, we also need to hear how the voices alter that balance.
Further reading
Look more closely
Compare Rath’s portrait with the shared scene. What do the room and the other people’s positions add?
08 / Film
M: a city listens and suspects
The murders of children change the behaviour of an entire city. Parents fear letting children into the street, passers-by suspect one another and the police search for the killer. Fear enters ordinary encounters and makes familiar spaces dangerous.
In his first sound film, Lang makes hearing part of the investigation. A whistled melody can announce a person before a face appears. Sound connects what we see with what lies outside the frame. Silence also acquires weight.
The screenshot shows a man and a girl beside a shop window, surrounded by toys, dolls, masks and reflections. In another context, this could be an everyday urban scene. Knowing the story makes us watch the distance between them and read each detail as a possible warning.
Peter Lorre creates a figure who resists the convenient category of a screen monster. Lang confronts us with crime, responsibility and collective cruelty, refusing to reduce the story to the satisfaction of catching a villain. Attention also turns towards those who claim the right to judge.
Our route ends here: from the solemn world of legend to a modern city with an unstable order, where a voice can expose a person and also demand to be heard.
Further reading
Look more closely
Study the shop window without the figures, then with them. How does your impression of the toys and reflections change?
Faces and connections
People behind the films
These films also let us follow the work of individual people. A director changes genres, an actor returns to a related theme in different roles, a face connects several films. Such comparisons reveal more than a sequence of titles and dates.
G. W. Pabst: a person among other people’s rules
Pabst is especially compelling where a personal fate meets social expectations. Money, reputation, dependence and the desire to preserve appearances become active forces. In Pandora’s Box, we can follow the changes in other people’s responses to Lulu, who never quite fits their explanations.
His direction draws attention to behaviour: an answering glance, a pause, a movement towards another person. Editing connects these details so that we follow relationships. An effective performance is inseparable from the precision of its screen setting.
The filmography brings together Pandora’s Box, Diary of a Lost Girl and The White Hell of Pitz Palu, co-directed with Arnold Fanck. Even this small selection shows how different a director’s tasks could be within a single year.
Further reading
Emil Jannings: the changing weight of a human figure
The gallery places the doorman from The Last Laugh alongside Mephistopheles in Faust, the protagonist of The Last Command and Professor Rath. One face acquires different physical qualities: fatigue, mockery, tension and self-assurance. Makeup and costume assist the transformation, but the gaze and the way the head is held sustain our attention.
For this essay, the connection between the doorman and the professor is especially revealing. Both recognise themselves through a particular social position. When it disappears, their movements, gestures and relationships with surrounding space change. Jannings makes the transformation visible before it is named.
Mephistopheles takes us back to the first essay; The Last Command takes us outside Germany, to an American film of 1928. The gallery therefore illustrates an actor’s range and connections between films, rather than the works of a single national cinema.
Louise Brooks: beyond a recognisable silhouette
Her black bob makes Brooks almost instantly recognisable. Yet a closer look at two roles reveals differences beneath the resemblance. Lulu in Pandora’s Box and Thymian in Diary of a Lost Girl inhabit different circumstances, look differently and respond differently to others.
Pabst directed both films in 1929. Together, they extend the question of how society treats a woman whose life fails to conform to its rules. Each heroine nevertheless requires individual attention: a shared face and hairstyle cannot explain her story.
In the character gallery, Lulu’s dark headscarf and the pale framing of Thymian’s face create almost opposite impressions. Comparison restores a variability easily lost when a face becomes a symbol of an entire era.
Further reading
One period, many ways of seeing
These films share no single appearance. The enormous forest of Die Nibelungen, a hotel washroom, an ice wall, a lunar rocket and a Sunday recreation spot propose very different relationships between people and space. That variety makes them rewarding to place side by side.
Behind directorial craft and technical invention lies a persistent attention to behaviour. How do we hold ourselves when others watch? What remains of dignity without a familiar social position? Where does desire become dependence, and a wish for order become cruelty? Such questions bring old films close.
A collection offers different routes back to them: a director, a performer, a genre or an individual image. Today we might compare two Jannings characters; next, notice how Lang changes scale from legend to city street. Then we can reopen a film we thought we already knew.
Illustrations: screenshots from a personal flickollect collection. Posters show different editions and reissues. Observations on composition and performances are editorial interpretations of the images.
↑ Back to top