← All film essays

The silent comedies of Hollywood

Where to begin with silent cinema? Chaplin at dinner, Keaton at the helm and Lloyd high above the street. A collector’s route through Hollywood comedy.

If someone asked me where to begin with silent cinema, I would put on a comedy. I was lucky enough to see The Gold Rush and City Lights on television as a child. For many viewers of my generation the small screen was where we met the Tramp, decades after the movies learned to talk.

When I started collecting films, it was the Essanay and Mutual shorts that brought me back to Chaplin. I would hesitate to recommend the four-hour version of Greed for a first evening. It takes a little time to find your bearings in an Ozu household or in Lang’s Metropolis. But once Lloyd is hanging over a street by the hand of a clock, I simply have to know how he is going to get down.

Harold Lloyd hanging from the hand of a clock above the street in Safety Last!

Charlie Chaplin

In the early shorts I used to watch the Tramp’s hands. In the features Chaplin still holds my attention in much the same way. I can forget who owes whom money and remember exactly how a man picks up a boot or a flower. His own studio gave him time to work out those scenes. He co-founded the distribution company United Artists and completed his First National contract before releasing his pictures through it. His drama A Woman of Paris belongs to another conversation.

The short comedies

In 1959 Chaplin revisited these three First National pictures, releasing them together as The Chaplin Revue with his own score. Five years separate the first two films from The Pilgrim. Seen together, they make a delightful record of all the occupations the Tramp could turn his hand to.

A Dog’s Life

1918

At the employment window the Tramp is elbowed aside. Beyond a fence a stray has to fight a pack for its food. Chaplin has introduced the pair before they ever meet. By the time they team up, the dog feels like an equal partner.

A Dog’s Life · Cast in character
A Dog’s Life · Film still

Shoulder Arms

1918

The recruit finds himself in a flooded trench. He would like to sleep, but where can he put his head? Chaplin brings the Tramp’s familiar problem of finding a bed into the trenches. When the soldier goes out disguised as a tree, we can believe he might put the whole landscape to work.

Shoulder Arms · Cast in character
Shoulder Arms · Film still

The Pilgrim

1923

An escaped convict has been mistaken for a minister and must deliver a sermon. His subject is David and Goliath. How do you explain what David did without so much as a sling? Soon the congregation has seen the whole fight. Watch the boy in the pews as well as the preacher. Here at last is a minister to his taste.

The Pilgrim · Cast in character
The Pilgrim · Film still

The Kid

1921

A boy breaks a window. Just in time, a glazier comes round the corner with a pane on his back. What a team! Chaplin and Jackie Coogan have shown us a family business before we have had a moment to question its ethics. By the time the orphanage van comes for the child, we know exactly what these two stand to lose.

At first the Tramp would happily have handed the baby on to anybody. Fatherhood begins with a practical difficulty. How do you feed somebody so small? He rigs up a coffee pot with a teat on its spout. Years later the boy is making pancakes for the two of them. A change in the breakfast arrangements tells us what those years have brought. There is somebody to look after the Tramp now, too.

The Kid · Cast in character
The Kid · Film still 1
The Kid · Film still 2

The Gold Rush

1925

A boiled boot is served for dinner in a Klondike cabin. The Tramp twirls a lace on his fork and sucks each nail as neatly as if it were a game bird’s bone. His table manners are so persuasive that for a moment we can taste the meal he imagines. Then we look down at the plate again.

On New Year’s Eve two bread rolls appear on the table. The Tramp spears them with his forks and a little dancer steps out across the cloth. It is lovely to have Georgia and her friends at supper this time. You can almost hear the little shoes tap. Chaplin lets the act run to its finish before returning us to the sleeping host and the empty places at his table. I always feel a little sorry to have enjoyed the dance so much that I forgot how long he had been waiting for company.

The Gold Rush · Cast in character
The Gold Rush · Film still 1
The Gold Rush · Film still 2

The Circus

1928

Fleeing a policeman, the Tramp stumbles into the ring and finally gives the audience something to laugh at. The proprietor wants a repeat performance. We get to see almost the same act twice. As soon as the Tramp knows where he ought to fall and where the laugh should come, he becomes a dreadful clown. It takes a remarkably precise performer to make spontaneity disappear on cue.

At the end the company moves on. A circle on the ground marks the spot where the whole circus stood, and sitting in the middle is the man the audience applauded. For the first time I get a good sense of the size of that ring. It seemed tiny while he was tearing around it. Now all he has to do is stand up and leave, and the far side of the circle looks a long way off.

The Circus · Cast in character
The Circus · Film still 1
The Circus · Film still 2

City Lights

1931

A blind flower seller hears a car door close and takes her customer for a wealthy man. We saw where the Tramp came from. She could only listen. For a film with a recorded score and sound effects, Chaplin devised a love story that begins with a mistake of hearing. At their last meeting, touch will settle the question. The recognition of a hand is what stays with me.

There is another person to whom the Tramp keeps becoming a stranger. Drunk, the millionaire embraces him as his dearest friend. Sober, he is astonished to find a ragged man in his house. Chaplin gets several good laughs out of that change of face. They come back to haunt the scene in the flower shop. What will the girl see in him now that she can look at him? His pleasure that she can see and his fear of her gaze are both there in his smile.

City Lights · Cast in character
City Lights · Film still 1
City Lights · Film still 2
↑ Contents

Buster Keaton

A glance at my collection shows how hard it is to choose among Keaton’s features. In the twenties alone he went out to sea, aboard a riverboat and into a locomotive cab. I would start with the shorts. There is time to see how Buster manages in a single room before watching him cope with a universe in which even the ground underfoot can suddenly disappear.

Keaton’s features in my collection

The short comedies

A house for two, a kitchen for two, a street where one man faces an entire police force. The scale of the problem changes with each film. Keaton gives us time to grasp how the trap works and even to devise an escape, which of course will never be the one he takes.

One Week

1920

Newlyweds receive a house in kit form. A rival switches the numbers on the crates, turning the builder’s exemplary diligence against him. The best part is that Keaton still means to live in the result.

One Week · Cast in character
One Week · Film still

The Scarecrow

1920

At breakfast two housemates pass the condiments by strings and pulleys. Try following each object on its journey. The contraption makes a lovely portrait of two people who have lived together long enough to know just when the other will want the salt.

The Scarecrow · Cast in character
The Scarecrow · Film still

Cops

1922

Keaton drives a wagon into a police parade. One mistake has many witnesses, each witness has a pair of legs, and soon a whole city in matching caps is running after him. From a distance the chase looks like a dance. From up close it is easy to see why Buster keeps a straight face.

Cops · Cast in character
Cops · Film still

Our Hospitality

1923

An old family feud obliges the young woman’s relatives to shoot her suitor. Hospitality obliges them to protect a guest. Once Keaton understands the rule, the funniest place in the house is the threshold. One step across it and the same courteous men have licence to kill. We start watching his feet.

First he has to reach that doorstep. On the way, a tiny train rattles along such precarious track that a passenger might do well to get out and help. Keaton lets us inspect the wheels and the whole stretch of rail ahead of them. Later, with the current carrying him towards a waterfall, I catch myself reckoning distances just as carefully. Now the few feet left before the drop will decide whether he can reach the girl in time.

Our Hospitality · Cast in character
Our Hospitality · Film still 1
Our Hospitality · Film still 2

Sherlock Jr.

1924

A projectionist falls asleep and walks into the picture he is showing. All he wants to do is sit down, but the editor keeps changing the terrain under his feet. A cut costs us a fraction of a second. Keaton has to pay for each one with his whole body. Even an ordinary cut in another film looks a little miraculous afterwards.

When the projectionist wakes up, he finds himself alone with his girl. This is where the screen comes in handy. Watch how the leading man takes the lady’s hand, turn back to your own sweetheart and do likewise. Courtship seems quite manageable after all. The trouble is that editing allows the couple on screen to get on with their lives awfully fast. I love Keaton’s final look of bewilderment. Having spent a whole film longing to get into the movies, how is he supposed to keep up with one?

Sherlock Jr. · Cast in character
Sherlock Jr. · Film still 1
Sherlock Jr. · Film still 2

The General

1926

Everything on the locomotive has weight and a purpose. A sleeper on the track is a threat. Another sleeper in the engineer’s hands might be the tool that saves him. Keaton keeps the obstruction and the distance to it in view. We have time to work out Johnny’s chances for ourselves, and the laugh of relief comes a fraction later than we would like.

The chase has a return leg. First Johnny pursues the stolen engine. Then he drives it home with the former fugitives in pursuit. We see the same railway through the eyes of someone who needs to buy a minute’s head start. Every sleeper that held him up on the outward trip now suggests a way to delay another train. Few adventure pictures reward you quite so generously for paying attention during the first half.

The General · Cast in character
The General · Film still 1
The General · Film still 2

Steamboat Bill, Jr.

1928

A father tries hats on his son. One glance in the mirror, another at his father, and we know both men rather well. Later a cyclone will bring the front of a house down on Keaton. The difference between life and death fits inside a window frame. Even after that spectacle I want to go back to the hats. The timing there is just as exact.

In the hat shop the father was deciding what a son fit for his steamboat ought to look like. During the storm he gets into trouble himself, and everything depends on this slight young fellow. The boy rigs lines to the boat’s controls so that one man can do the work of a crew. It is a good moment to remember his father’s dismay at their first meeting. Finding the boy a suitable hat was much easier than seeing the sailor in him.

Steamboat Bill, Jr. · Cast in character
Steamboat Bill, Jr. · Film still 1
Steamboat Bill, Jr. · Film still 2

The Cameraman

1928

The aspiring newsreel man buys a camera. Getting through a disturbance in one piece used to be quite enough for a Keaton hero. Now he also has to pick a spot from which an audience can see it, set up a tripod and turn the crank. Imagine doing the job well only to find that a reporter’s fate hangs on who has the reel.

There is a wonderful moment when there is absolutely nothing to film. Alone in an empty baseball stadium, Buster plays out a whole game. Following his eyes, we begin to track the flight of a ball that isn’t there. The actor has only to turn his head for us to see the sporting event the novice cameraman has been hunting for in vain. My favourite detail is that the empty stands remain in plain sight.

The Cameraman · Cast in character
The Cameraman · Film still 1
The Cameraman · Film still 2
↑ Contents

Harold Lloyd

I came to Lloyd later. For years I owned only the film with the clock. After starting flickollect I added more of his features and was surprised at how many different people a young man in the same round glasses could play. He sincerely wants a promotion, a girl’s affection, his brothers’ respect. Of the three comedians, his embarrassments feel the most familiar to me.

Safety Last!

1923

For years the Lloyd in my collection was the man hanging from a clock. I knew the image long before I wondered what had sent him up the wall. A department store clerk has devised a publicity stunt to impress his employer. At every floor he hopes his friend can take over. The storeys look alike only from the pavement. Seen up close, each has a fresh indignity in store.

The store has been preparing us for the climb long before we get outside. During a sale Harold is wedged between the counter and his customers, devising elaborate manoeuvres to serve people he can barely reach. When he steps out on a ledge, I recognise the resourceful clerk going about his work. The poster may leave him hanging over the abyss for ever. What I treasure in the film is his businesslike air. He is on duty, and it is turning out to be a difficult shift.

Safety Last! · Cast in character
Safety Last! · Film still 1
Safety Last! · Film still 2

The Freshman

1925

Harold goes to college having learned from the movies how to be the best-liked fellow on campus. He has even rehearsed a greeting. We can see the looks exchanged behind his back. When his hastily basted suit starts to come apart at the dance, I want to laugh and shield him from the room at the same time.

Keep an eye on the tailor at the dance. He has to catch each parting seam while Harold attends to his partner, who is meant to see a perfectly turned-out young man. For her it is one dance. From where we sit there are two going on at once. Keeping up appearances at any cost seems such a merry enterprise at first that it hurts all the more when Harold finally understands what has made him so well known on campus.

The Freshman · Cast in character
The Freshman · Film still 1
The Freshman · Film still 2

The Kid Brother

1927

The youngest in a family of strong men is left to keep house. Lloyd gives him a wonderful moment of courtship. As the girl walks away, he climbs higher in a tree to keep her in sight. The man who scaled a building for his career climbs here for a few more seconds with the girl he loves. What a lyrical actor he turns out to be.

Lloyd gives us time to appreciate Harold’s abilities long before his family takes notice. At home he has ingenuity enough to get a whole household’s laundry done. He needs that same ingenuity aboard a derelict ship with a man who can easily overpower him. His brothers could have discovered what their kid brother was worth much sooner if they had ever paid attention on washday.

The Kid Brother · Cast in character
The Kid Brother · Film still 1
The Kid Brother · Film still 2

Speedy

1928

New York moves in every direction at once. Among the cars and crowds a horse-drawn streetcar still runs, and our hero sets out to save it. On Coney Island Lloyd can vanish among real holidaymakers. In his cab he gets Babe Ruth himself as a passenger. I treasure the film as a walk through a city whose people sometimes have no idea they have wandered into a comedy.

After work the neighbours gather in Grandpa Dillon’s horsecar much as they might at a club. That changes the chase for me. Of course it is fun to see what speed a man nicknamed Speedy can coax out of the old car. But while it rattles along I am also thinking about the people who will want to sit there that evening. Lloyd has made a rather lovely city hero. Always in a hurry himself, he goes to a great deal of trouble to save a place where other people can linger.

Speedy · Cast in character
Speedy · Film still 1
Speedy · Film still 2
↑ Contents

Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy

A double act offers a pleasure all its own. With Laurel and Hardy there is always a second man on hand who can register, in a single look, the full extent of the trouble the first has just got them into. For an introduction to the pair I have chosen the story of an attempt to sell a Christmas tree.

Big Business

1929

Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy are selling Christmas trees. James Finlayson shuts his door on them. A little patience on either side and everyone could go home. Instead, grown men take turns destroying a house and a car. The funniest moment often comes in the pause when a man has finished his piece of vandalism, stepped back and waits with almost courteous interest for a reply. Try playing that scene alone.

Big Business · Cast in character
Big Business · Film still 1
Big Business · Film still 2
↑ Contents

After sound arrived

When the movies learned to talk, these three men took very different paths. As late as 1931 Chaplin could release City Lights with a recorded score and let the Tramp keep his silence. Amid political persecution, his departure from the United States in 1952 turned into exile. He continued making films in Europe and even found the appetite to compose new music for his early comedies.

Keaton had lost much of his freedom as a filmmaker when he went to MGM near the end of the silent era. He acted in talkies, devised gags for others and later worked in television. Lloyd also made several sound comedies. As the years passed, new audiences had fewer occasions to see his films. In the sixties he helped bring them back himself, gathering favourite sequences into Harold Lloyd’s World of Comedy.

There is one pleasure I wish for anyone discovering silent comedy today. Play the bit that made you laugh a second time. Now you can watch the fellow in the corner of the frame, patiently waiting for his turn to close a door. It turns out you owe some of that laugh to him.